home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=91TT2248>
- <title>
- Oct. 07, 1991: 1492 vs. 1892 vs. 1992
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1991
- Oct. 07, 1991 Defusing the Nuclear Threat
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- HISTORY, Page 61
- 1492 vs. 1892 vs. 1992
- </hdr><body>
- <p>At three imperial moments, three Columbuses reveal something
- about their different eras
- </p>
- <p>By Garry Wills
- </p>
- <p> The year 1492 was Spain's annus mirabilis, a year of
- marvels. A Spanish Pope was elected that year, a Borja from
- Catalonia. (He was called Borgia in Italy, where the Two
- Sicilies already had Spanish rulers.) King Ferdinand and Queen
- Isabella, who had just united their kingdoms, drove the Moors
- from the Spanish peninsula by a military victory at Granada.
- Spain's Jews were expelled in the same year, solidifying the
- Inquisition's power.
- </p>
- <p> Columbus was part of all this. He would supply the Spanish
- Pope with information that led to the partition of the New
- World into Spanish and Portuguese spheres in 1493. He was with
- his monarchs at Granada to celebrate the Moorish victory, and
- he saw the last Jews depart from Seville harbors the day before
- he set out on his first journey west. He viewed this
- concatenation of events as a sign of the world's fulfillment,
- and predicted that the gold he brought back would finance an
- ultimate Crusade to reclaim the Holy Land.
- </p>
- <p> Spain was establishing what historian J.H. Plumb calls
- "the greatest empire since antiquity." This modern empire was
- built, as Plumb also notes, on the basis of medieval theology.
- Yet much of Europe and most of the New World would become the
- domain of Charles V, and then of Philip III, making the next
- hundred years the Spanish Century.
- </p>
- <p> The year 1892 was an annus mirabilis in the U.S. The best
- symbol of that was Chicago, a city leveled by fire as recently
- as 1871 but subsequently bristling with the continent's first
- cluster of skyscrapers. For the 1893 World's Fair that became
- known as the World's Columbian Exposition, Daniel Burnham and
- a panel of America's greatest architects created a gleaming new
- Exposition city on Lake Michigan. Henry Adams, arriving in the
- private train car of a Pennsylvania Senator, was struck with a
- vision of a new America; he returned alone to spend two weeks
- studying the event, "more surprising, as it was, than anything
- else on the continent." He consciously imitated Edward Gibbon
- on the steps of the Expo's Administration Building--but where
- Gibbon, sitting on the steps of Rome's Aracoeli church, had a
- vision of the falling Roman Empire, Adams saw a rising empire.
- Another visitor to the fair, historian Frederick Jackson Turner,
- delivered a famous paper there, saying that the internal
- frontier was closed; but America would, by the end of the
- decade, add to its dominion Hawaii, Puerto Rico, the
- Philippines, Guam, Samoa and Wake Island, while occupying Cuba.
- The American Century had begun.
- </p>
- <p> The Columbus honored in Chicago bore little resemblance to
- the medieval wizard of Spain's inquisitorial empire. That
- ancient mariner was now conceived to be a champion of
- Anglo-Saxon (Protestant) values. The Spaniards had taken guns
- and the catechism abroad. America, said Mark Twain, took guns
- and the King James Bible to the Philippines, and President
- McKinley said he would make the island inhabitants good
- Christians. For the Chicago fair, sculptor Daniel Chester
- French, creator of American icons like the seated Lincoln in the
- Lincoln Memorial, fashioned a 14-ft. statue of Columbus driving
- an imperial chariot.
- </p>
- <p> As we approach 1992, it promises to be an annus not so
- mirabilis for America--a strange thing, since we are reaching
- the end of that American Century launched on the last major
- Columbian centenary. During the past hundred years, America has
- exercised a global authority not even Henry Adams could have
- foreseen. Yet we seem not in the celebrating mood. Chicago
- turned down the honor of mounting another Columbian Exposition.
- Our federal commission on the quincentennial floundered in
- scandal and ineptitude during the six years John Goudie presided
- over it. The Columbus now being described is a rather bedraggled
- figure, a symbol of empire in a postcolonial age, when most of
- the world is celebrating the breakup of empires, not their
- inception. The facts about Columbus always mattered less, to his
- admirers, than the uses he could be put to. Those uses have, by
- now, drastically shrunk.
- </p>
- <p> For three imperial moments, then, we have had three
- different Columbuses--each telling us something about a
- different age. Only our third period is a post imperial moment.
- We Americans have been able to rejoice at the collapse of the
- Soviet empire. But we were mild (to say the least) in our
- celebrations as European colonial systems dissolved over the
- last half of the century, creating a whole map of new nations
- in a Third World that contains most of the globe's population.
- </p>
- <p> Ironically, 1992 may turn out to be an annus mirabilis for
- Europe, once the center of colonial empires. The new freedoms
- in Eastern Europe, the easing of hostile pressures from the
- Soviet bloc and the European Community's economic integration
- in 1992 may bring life back to the source of Western energy. The
- E.C. itself comes from a realization that these old countries
- must cope with postimperial realities. If there is a new world
- order, this realism should be its basis.
- </p>
- <p> Multiculturalism is not a plot of some left-wing
- professors in the U.S.; it is the most obvious of global facts,
- in a world where the "natives" are telling Columbus how to
- behave, rather than the reverse. That, oddly, is a cause for
- celebration. The next century will not be America's to call its
- own--or any other single nation's. We are all in one boat
- together, and Columbus must travel with us now as a fellow
- passenger, no longer the skipper.
- </p>
-
- </body></article>
- </text>
-
-